The suspension system of an electric scooter is crucial for both riding comfort and safety. Spring suspension and hydraulic suspension are two common systems, each with distinct differences in terms of working principles, performance, and user experience. Below is an in-depth analysis of these two suspension systems:
1. Working Principle
-
Spring Suspension: Spring suspension relies on the elasticity of springs to absorb and mitigate shocks from the road. When the scooter encounters uneven terrain, the spring compresses, absorbing part of the shock energy, and then releases it through rebound. This type of suspension is relatively simple in structure, usually consisting of coil springs made from steel or other high-strength materials.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension uses hydraulic fluid passing through internal pistons and valves to absorb shocks. When the scooter encounters uneven terrain, the piston in the hydraulic suspension is pushed into the oil chamber, and the hydraulic fluid passes through valves to slow down the movement of the piston, gradually absorbing the shock energy. Hydraulic suspension systems often combine with springs to provide dual cushioning effects.
2. Suspension Performance
-
Spring Suspension: The performance of spring suspension depends on the hardness and shape of the spring. Generally, softer springs are better for minor road irregularities, while harder springs are more suitable for larger impacts. However, spring suspension may produce a rebound effect, meaning that after absorbing the shock, the spring quickly rebounds, which can cause instability during the ride.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension offers smoother and more stable shock absorption because the damping effect of the hydraulic fluid effectively controls the movement of the piston, preventing excessive rebound. Hydraulic suspension can adapt to various road conditions, providing consistent shock absorption from minor vibrations to major impacts, making it perform better in diverse riding environments.
3. Comfort
-
Spring Suspension: Spring suspension can provide a comfortable riding experience to some extent, especially when dealing with mildly uneven roads. However, when encountering larger impacts, the spring may not sufficiently absorb the vibrations, leading to a rougher and less comfortable ride.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension significantly improves riding comfort due to its superior damping control. It effectively smooths out vibrations from various road surfaces, providing a more stable ride, particularly on long rides or rough terrain, where the advantages of hydraulic suspension become more apparent.
4. Durability and Maintenance
-
Spring Suspension: Spring suspension is simple in structure and generally durable, requiring less maintenance. Over time, springs may experience fatigue or deformation, but typically, this type of suspension system has a long lifespan and lower replacement costs.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension systems are more complex and require regular checks and maintenance, especially regarding the condition of seals and hydraulic fluid. While hydraulic suspension is generally durable, any issues, such as hydraulic fluid leaks or seal failures, can be complex and costly to repair.
5. Responsiveness
-
Spring Suspension: Spring suspension is highly responsive, quickly reacting to changes in the road surface. However, the rapid elastic recovery can lead to a "bouncing" effect, especially when encountering continuous small bumps, potentially making the ride less stable.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension uses the damping effect of hydraulic fluid to effectively cushion rebound speed, providing a smoother response. This means that even on bumpy roads, hydraulic suspension can maintain relatively stable performance, reducing the impact of vibrations.
6. Cost and Complexity
-
Spring Suspension: Due to its simple structure, spring suspension has lower manufacturing and installation costs, making it suitable for budget-conscious users or lower-cost electric scooters. Its simple design also makes it easier to maintain over time.
-
Hydraulic Suspension: Hydraulic suspension systems have higher manufacturing and installation costs and are typically used in high-end or performance-oriented electric scooters. The complex design and higher maintenance needs also translate to higher long-term costs.
Conclusion
Both spring suspension and hydraulic suspension have their own advantages. Spring suspension is ideal for light riding needs and budget-conscious users due to its simplicity, durability, and low cost. However, hydraulic suspension excels in performance, comfort, and responsiveness, making it particularly suitable for users who require high performance and ride on various challenging terrains. For those seeking ultimate comfort and stability, hydraulic suspension is undoubtedly the better choice.
🔗Product link：
- Molo 5 hydraulic suspension（1）
- 610mm 630mm hydraulic suspension（2）
- Obarter X7 hydraulic suspension（3）
Follow us for more:
- Official Website: https://geofought.com/
- Official WhatsApp: +86 18061415952
- Official WeChat: +86 18361618144
Contact Us
- Customer Service Hotline: +86 18061415952
- Email: Shirley008@geofought.com